- Account
- Join for Free
- Sign In
- Help & Info
- Privacy Notice
- DMCA
- Contact Us
- Terms Of Use
erna ve aymen s 3 What is This Goin to Cost Me? October 4 2008 3:45 p.m. 3 5:00 p.m.
COPYRIGHT NOTICE The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the ma ng o p o ocop es or o er repro uc on o copyr g e ma er a . n er cer a n conditions specified in the law, libraries and archives are authorized to furnish a photocopy or other reproduction. One of these specified conditions is that the hotoco or re roduction is not to be "used for other ur ose than rivate stud scholarship or research." If a user makes a request for, or later uses, a photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excess of "fair use," that person may be liable for copyright infringement.
DISCLAIMER The opinions of the contributors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the National Association of Convenience Stores. Reference herein to any specific commercial products, process, or service by trade name, trademark manufacturer, or otherwise, shall not constitute or imply an , , Convenience Stores. The National Association of Convenience ... more.
less.
Stores makes no warranty, express or implied, nor does it assume any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, product, or process described in these materials.<br><br> t s o ery - , , CSP News July 23, 2008 The Interchange Challenge Continues Cost of non 0 cash 0 Ne ative + acceptance increases cash transactions = bottom line impact RATES INCREASE " Interchange rates VOLUME INCREASES " 93.3 billion non 0 cash transactions in 2006 PROFITS DECREASE " Decrease in overall rofits " Higher fuel and product prices " Increased securit " Debit transactions overcome credit transactions in 2006 " Increased spend in related technology investments requirements Is there a silver bullet??? Source: The 2007 Federal Reserve Payments Study No Silver Bullet " No one strategy will minimize the impact of interchange " Different strategies can be implemented to mitigate the impact Today 9s 3 Increase use of cheaper forms of payments " Loyalty/reward programs drive the use of lower cost payments " Prom t a ro riatel Discussion 3 Improve payments basic (blocking and tackling) " Ensure transactions are qualifying correctly " Review processing agreements 3 Marketing efforts to drive lower cost transactions " Discount for cash " Reward PIN Debit transactions Key Decisions for a Program " , , " Strategy (Graduation, Gas Card, Coalition) " Ava a e Pro ucts " Your Offer " Selection of Products and Vendors " General Marketer Objectives " " Increase vo ume Passive Approach " 3 Marketer will realize lower acceptance costs just by accepting 3 Suppliers take on primary responsibility and cost to issue " Products 3 Revolution Money 3 PIN Debit Impact of PIN Debit " e $40 = $0.45 $40 = $0.30 (cap is $0.95) (cap is $0.32) The Potential Impact Small changes can make a difference Acce tance Cost & Potential Savin s $30,000 $30,000 $31,000 payment mix is not easy and should not be $2,000 $2,071 $26,000 $27,000 $28,000 " A strong consumer value prop is required to drive , , $23,000 $24,000 $25,000 nt % % % % " Savings are feasible and comparable amongst 0 Curre Mi Rev = ACH = Rev = 1 ACH = 1 alternative options , " Acceptance rate of current mix is 2.3% and alternative payments = 0.50% Active Approach " 3 Requires marketer to be actively involved in issuance 3 May require marketer to make technology changes 3 Marketer is responsible for rewards " Products 3 Closed Loop (ACH or Credit) 3 Open Loop (ACH or Credit) 3 Gift cards Alternative Payment Overview " ACH Decou led Debit : HSBC Tem o National Payment Card, Kick Back, FDC, Maverick, etc. Today 9s " PIN Credit : Revolution Money Focus " Stored Value: Gift cards, prepaid, loyalty / rewards programs " Online: PayPal, Bill Me Later, NACHA Secure Vault, Alternative Payment Comparisons Generally Products cceptance ost .<br><br> 3 . . + .<br><br> . to . Most Pervasive New Entrant Watch Them Considerations " Does not include PIN Debit 0 and Grocery early adopters " Risk is brick 0 and 0 mortar presence base " Mobile may be path to brick 0 consumer s willingness to sign up " ssues an co 0 brands an 0 mor ar Merchant Options for Reducing Active Different Form Factors Retailer Branded Online Mobile National Stored HSBC Merchant Participation Card Va ue Cards Kick Back Passive Emerging Products PIN Debit Revolution N/A Acceptance Cost Relief Low Moderate Optimizing Savings National Stored Value ct ve eren orm ac ors e a er ran e Online Mobile Issuance & Marketing " Ensure alignment with your brand Participation Acceptance of Emerging Methods include: Passive Products Revolution Only " Reward programs " Cross promotions " Coalition programs Acceptance Cost Relief Low Moderate Long Term Goal!<br><br> National Stored Value National Active Different Form Factors Retailer Branded Online Mobile " Support alternative payment pilots " Accept alternative payment products " aymen ar ar s aymen ar Participation Toda : Limited Tomorrow: Passive Companies Revolution N A Consumer Base Market Share (2% 0 5%) Acceptance Cost Relief Low Moderate Success with Alternative Payments " Select the product, form and supplier(s) that match your offer and values " View Alternative Payments as a product 3 Consumer uptake is the responsibility of the retailer " Differentiate your product " Tie to food or product promotions (Starbucks) 3 Consider offering different modalities, " NFC (cards, stickers, fobs, mobile, etc.) " Know the regulations and your exposure 3 ACH product is regulated by NACHA Game Reset What are the considerations and implications for accepting alternative a ments? " Payment types are evolving and will continue to evo ve " Security requirements will continue to change and " POS & infrastructure decisions are long term (5 to 10 Key Implementation Considerations " Does my POS support the new payment type and the " Does my processor support this payment type? partners?<br><br> " Do I have the necessar infrastructure PIN ads pump types, controllers)? Select Supplier Comparisons NPC Tempo, Maverick Revolution Kickback Type ecoup e e (Closed Loop) ecoup e e (Open Loop) PIN Credit ecoup e e (Closed Loop) An POS that An POS that G 0 Site, Ruby, Acceptance Ruby accepts PIN Debit accepts PIN Debit app re, Passport, and Nucleus Processors Direct to NPC Anywhere MasterCard is accepted , Lynk (working on others) Direct to Kickback Loyalty / Reward Need Loyalty Need Loyalty Need Loyalty Integrated with Product Considerations When Choosing a " Alignment with your needs Offer compatibility 3 Technology requirements " p ron nves men " Supplier Viability / Sustainability " Security " Service To you 3 To your customers Other Ways to Lower Costs " Review processing contract 3 Seek Transparency Terms should be cInterchange Plus d 3 Watch for hidden fees and markups 3 3 year max length " Audit your current transactions 0 Get the best possible interchange qualifications Root cause analysis of downgrades 3 Don 9t assume your bank/processor does this for you! " uppor n o y ng e or s 3 H.R.<br><br> 5546 Credit Card Fee Act of 2008 . . Closing Thoughts " Accept lower cost cnon 0 alternative payments d PIN Debit; private label; gift cards " Request your processor to turn on alternative paymen pro uc s " Payments and rewards/loyalty are linked " oose t e r g t supp ers " Seek help in supplier selection and implementation Terry Mahoney Doug Rodewald Partner Partner .<br><br> . dblotter@wcapra.com raycroft@wcapra.com recordings available for purc ase workshop area or . at www.nacsonline.com NACS Member Prices Pa er Co : 175.00 Additional Copies: $40.00 Electronic Version: $500.00 - Paper Copy: $600.00 Additional Copies: $175.00 , .<br><br> 0 , 3 3 , Applications available February 2009.